Workforce Crisis in High-Social-Value Professions Demands New Solutions

Workforce Crisis in High-Social-Value Professions Demands New Solutions

Workforce Crisis in High-Social-Value Professions Demands New Solutions

Why It Matters

High-social-value professions like teaching, nursing, and social work face critical workforce shortages despite their essential role in community wellbeing.

The Big Picture

These shortages particularly impact rural and urban communities, with specific skill gaps in areas like special education, mental health services, and specialized nursing roles.

Key Challenges

  • Regulatory barriers and clinical requirements make it difficult for working adults to transition into these careers
  • Traditional education models often include costly, non-essential coursework
  • Tuition costs frequently outweigh potential salary earnings

Emerging Solutions

  • Employer-funded education programs with service commitments
  • Technology-enabled learning replacing traditional lecture formats
  • “Grow your own” programs helping organizations develop internal talent

What’s Next

Success requires coordination between policymakers, educators, and employers to create more accessible pathways into these vital professions while ensuring proper skill development.

Excelsior: Cognitive Skills Remain Important in Age of AI

Excelsior: Cognitive Skills Remain Important in Age of AI

Excelsior: Cognitive Skills Remain Important in Age of AI

The Big Picture

Higher education needs to intentionally develop critical thinking and cognitive abilities – not just technical skills – to prepare students for the modern workforce.

Why it matters

  • Employers increasingly value “soft skills” like communication, emotional intelligence and critical thinking alongside technical expertise
  • Even with AI’s rise, human cognitive abilities like asking good questions and applying knowledge remain crucial

The bottom line

While technical skills matter, higher education’s greatest value comes from developing students’ broader cognitive abilities to think critically and apply knowledge effectively across contexts.

Northern Virginia Community College Innovates the Internship to Speed Students from Learning to Earning

Northern Virginia Community College Innovates the Internship to Speed Students from Learning to Earning

By President Anne M. Kress, PhD

Northern Virginia Community College (NOVA) consistently looks for opportunities to respond to demand signals from regional employers and, thereby, build pathways to jobs that help Virginians climb the economic ladder. When new fields, such as data center operations, emerge in our region, we partner with industry leaders to create training that opens doors to jobs in those fields. In a landscape of changing skills, technologies, and careers, NOVA is also dedicated to understanding our residents’ and businesses’ evolving employment needs and seeking innovative, cost-effective ways of responding.

Many signals indicate that young people increasingly seek to enter the workforce quickly and recognize that real-world experience is what will position them for success. Recent national survey results reveal two-thirds of high school students prefer their postsecondary experience to include hands-on or on-the-job learning. An April 2024 report from the National Student Clearinghouse Research Center found more students earned a certificate from an institution of higher education during the 2022-2023 academic year than in any of the last 10 years. Slightly more than half the growth was attributed to first-time certificate earners who were 18- to 20-year-olds: they know that work-based learning matters more than ever.

At the same time, businesses in many states across the country, including Virginia, are experiencing severe labor shortages, according to the U.S. Chamber of Commerce. The Virginia Chamber of Commerce also reports the top concern of businesses in the Commonwealth is access to qualified talent. More than half strongly agree Virginia should make investments that increase the number of paid internships, co-op programs, and other work-based learning experiences available to college students. Like the students themselves, Virginia businesses know that hands-on experiences both expand and strengthen the early-career talent pipeline.

One way NOVA is responding to both students and businesses is by innovating the internship. Our goal has been preserving what makes an internship so valuable: it is a real-world learning experience that enables students to develop professional skills, create networks, and discover potential career opportunities. Central to a successful internship has long been strong faculty and supervisor mentorship. NOVA’s task was to keep these elements while making the traditional concept relevant to today’s learners and employers.

Our reimagined internships differ in two ways from the traditional model. First, NOVA offers internships to new groups of students. Internships and work-based learning opportunities have long been available to those pursuing associate degrees directly connected to careers, such as health care or information technology (IT). NOVA knew that if internships made the difference for students’ economic advancement, they needed to be available across the curriculum. And second, NOVA saw that the traditional length of internships was a barrier to entry for students who were balancing college with work and caring for children and family members. Internships needed to be reimagined as shorter-term assignments focused around project-based assignments rather than the more common semester-length or summer experiences. This targeted approach could also have the benefit of isolating and validating in-demand skills.

One of NOVA’s most exciting internship initiatives, called Real World Experience (RWX), involves creating opportunities for learners in the NOVA Workforce division, a novel concept in internship design. Envisioned to last 40 hours, these internships will be made available to students who have completed IT courses and passed the relevant certification exam, earning industry-recognized credentials in CompTIA A+, Network+, and Security+, for example. Although these industry-designed courses prepare students for established positions, NOVA believes the addition of a small, concentrated amount of hands-on experience will ensure students can enter the workforce without delay.  Beginning in late spring, our college will pilot the effort, and the first interns will intern with NOVA IT professionals throughout the college.

NOVA students following humanities/liberal arts pathways also find internship opportunities designed specifically for them, thanks to a grant from the Jack, Joseph and Morton Mandel Foundation. These internships, offered in a range of employer settings, including NOVA departments, will allow students to build high-value, high-demand technical and professional skills while gaining exposure to jobs in fields they might not have previously considered. NOVA has validated these skills with local employers, so we have confidence that the skills and knowledge students acquire in the classroom as English or psychology majors combined with those built in the workplace will position graduates to enter meaningful, well-paid positions in our local economy.

NOVA’s partnership with the Smithsonian Institution’s National Museum of Asian Art exemplifies our doubling down on innovation in internships. Any NOVA student can apply to participate in the museum’s prestigious, well-paid summer internships. In addition to learning about museum work in general, interns are matched with one department relevant to their interests or career goals. Our interns have contributed so much to the museum that, for the fourth year in a row, it has set aside half of all internships specifically for NOVA students. NOVA student London Allen called the museum internship “a unique and exciting time” that was “essential for [my] growth both as a student and as a young career professional.” It’s hard to imagine a more powerful endorsement of the value of an internship. From the galleries of the Smithsonian to the servers at our college to the seats in our classrooms, NOVA is committed to connecting all interested students with internships that fast track the path from learning to earning.

AI’s Not a Genie in a Lamp: It’s a Space to Think

AI’s Not a Genie in a Lamp: It’s a Space to Think

AI’s Not a Genie in a Lamp: It’s a Space to Think

The big picture:

Author Josh Thorpe argues against viewing AI as either a “magic power” or “just a tool” — instead advocating for seeing it as an interactive learning environment.

Why it matters

As educational institutions grapple with AI integration, Thorpe’s perspective offers a middle ground between complete rejection and uncritical acceptance.

Key insights

  • Students generally fall into three categories:
    • Those overwhelmed by new tech
    • Those using AI to cheat
    • Those who thoughtfully integrate AI into learning

Bottom line

AI in education works best when it prompts students to think more deeply rather than doing the thinking for them.

February CHIPS Update

February CHIPS Update

In a significant development for the CHIPS and Science Act implementation, on January 16th, the Department of Commerce announced preliminary funding agreements totaling approximately $246.4 million across four semiconductor companies. The proposed investments include:

  • $105 million for Analog Devices to expand facilities in Massachusetts, Oregon, and Washington
  • $79 million for Coherent’s silicon carbide substrate production in Pennsylvania
  • $10.3 million for IntelliEPI’s epitaxial wafer facility in Texas
  • $52.1 million for Sumika’s new ultra-high purity chemical plant in Texas

These investments aim to strengthen domestic semiconductor manufacturing capabilities, create approximately 1,190 new jobs across multiple states, and enhance the U.S. semiconductor supply chain. The initiatives span various critical areas including RF microwave systems, silicon carbide substrates, epitaxial wafers, and high-purity chemicals essential for chip production.

In another significant development, the Department of Commerce has finalized three new CHIPS Act awards totaling $143 million, along with a $75 million supplemental award to GlobalFoundries. The latest funding allocations include:

  • $32 million for Corning’s HPFS and ULE glass production expansion in Canton, New York
  • $18 million for Edwards Vacuum’s new semiconductor dry pump facility in Genesee County, New York
  • $93 million for Infinera’s photonic semiconductor manufacturing in San Jose, California and Bethlehem, Pennsylvania

These investments will create approximately 730 manufacturing jobs and 1,475 construction jobs across multiple states. The projects focus on critical components for semiconductor manufacturing, including lithography materials, vacuum pumps for fab operations, and photonic integrated circuits for data communications. The additional $75 million awarded to GlobalFoundries will support advanced packaging technology development at their Malta, New York facility.

The Presidents Forum continues to actively monitor and engage with CHIPS for America developments, recognizing the critical importance of semiconductor manufacturing to U.S. economic and national security interests. Through regular briefings and policy discussions, the Forum maintains close involvement with these initiatives, ensuring its members stay informed about funding allocations, implementation progress, and emerging opportunities in the semiconductor industry.

Northern Virginia Community College: Expanding Opportunities in the Skilled Trades

Northern Virginia Community College: Expanding Opportunities in the Skilled Trades

By Dr. Anne Kress, Northern Virginia Community College

In 2025, Northern Virginia Community College (NOVA) will continue its focus on offering more opportunities for individuals in our region to develop the skills, knowledge, and credentials they need to enter jobs in Virginia’s high-growth industries. With new investments from public and private sources and guided by data that identify in-demand jobs, NOVA will expand workforce-focused programs in the skilled trades, offering new state-of-the-art labs and equipment. Our goal is two-fold: to enable more Virginians to accelerate their steps up the economic ladder and to meet the needs of the growing regional economy. 

Virginia is currently among the 16 states in the nation experiencing the most severe labor shortages, according to the U.S. Chamber of Commerce. Overall, there are only 47 available workers for every 100 open job positions. Digging deeper into shortages in the skilled trades, research by McKinsey & Company, using U.S. Bureau of Labor data, found there were more than half a million openings for welders, cutters, solderers and braziers as of January 2024, an extraordinarily high number. Because welders are required to produce approximately 70% of all manufactured goods, such a significant shortage can limit production, jeopardize quality, and lower business productivity. 

NOVA’s own Labor Market Intelligence and Business Engagement teams confirm strong local demand for workers in skilled trades such as welding and heating, ventilation and air conditioning (HVAC), and that employers are struggling to find those workers. Amazon’s announcement in 2023 that it will invest $35 billion in new data centers in the Commonwealth will intensify the demand for skilled trade workers such as electricians, HVAC technicians, plumbers, fiber optic technicians, and more to build, operate, and maintain the facilities that power the Internet services essential to modern life and business.

This data led NOVA to invest in our capacity to provide a workforce for the skills trades—and in 2025, this investment will begin to strengthen the talent pipeline. 

This year, NOVA will renovate welding and HVAC labs on two campuses and add new lab space at a third. These improvements and expansions will double the capacity of our welding program. The HVAC program also will have increased capacity and a new focus on commercial HVAC. The economic results for students seeking these pathways are real and significant: according to Virginia Office of Education Economics (VOEE) data, the current median earnings per year for heating, air conditioning and refrigeration mechanics in the Northern Virginia area is $65,399 while median annual earnings for welders, cutters and solderers is $49,240. 

At our Manassas Campus, NOVA will break ground on the Center for Building and Construction Trades, a state-of-the-art facility designed with input from industry that will allow us to enroll even more students in welding and HVAC programs and introduce new certificate programs in diesel engine mechanics, electric vehicle repair, generator installation and repair, electrical programming, and maintenance technician. To create even further and faster opportunities for students’ career growth and greater earnings, NOVA will to design these certificate programs to stack into associates degrees. 

Expanding access to high-quality programs leading to high-demand jobs is an essential first step toward meeting the needs of the communities we serve, but our success depends on the outcomes of these programs. We are holding ourselves accountable to NOVA’s strategic plan and the Virginia Community College System’s strategic plan, both of which establish numeric goals to achieve by 2026. NOVA will increase by 20% the number of students enrolled in the highest-earning pathways, including workforce and transfer pathways. We will also increase by 20% the number of credentials and degrees awarded in the highest-earning pathways. These are jobs identified by the Virginia Office of Education Economics (VOEE) as high-demand occupations that require less than a bachelor’s degree and offer an annual wage high enough to provide economic stability, among other criteria. These improvements contribute to our system goals to increase the number of VCCS graduates who achieve greater economic mobility (40%) and stability (50%)—and even more importantly, they transform the lives of our students by connecting them to meaningful jobs and real economic opportunity. 

Offering these pathways to well-paid jobs responds directly to the growing number of Americans seeking economic opportunity through means other than traditional higher education. At a time when more Americans are questioning the value of traditional higher education, NOVA is responding to residents of the Commonwealth and its businesses with new opportunities that lead to economic mobility and community prosperity. Or in the words of Caroline P., who earned a Career Studies Certificate in welding last May, “I definitely plan to make a career out of welding with what I learned at NOVA.”

The world and the workplace are changing. At the Presidents Forum, we believe that higher education must keep pace. That’s why we were formed in 2002, and why we continue our work to this day to reinvent higher education through innovation to benefit all student learners.

© 2024 Presidents Forum, All rights reserved.

WHO WE ARE

NEWSROOM

80 M Street SE, # 130
Washington DC 20003

The world and the workplace are changing. At the Presidents Forum, we believe that higher education must keep pace. That’s why we were formed in 2002, and why we continue our work to this day to reinvent higher education through innovation to benefit all student learners.

80 M Street SE, # 130
Washington DC 20003

© 2024 Presidents Forum, All rights reserved.